by Ron Friedman
Originally published in Fast Company • August 24, 2012
The biggest decision-making mistakes rarely come from having too little information. More often, they come from chasing one more fact that feels important but quietly distracts us from what matters most.
That’s the question raised by Princeton and Stanford University psychologists in a fascinating study titled On the Pursuit and Misuse of Useless Information.
Their experiment was simple. Participants were divided into two groups. Group 1 read the following:
Imagine that you are a loan officer at a bank reviewing the mortgage application of a recent college graduate with a stable, well-paying job and a solid credit history. The applicant seems qualified, but during the routine credit check you discover that for the last three months the applicant has not paid a $5,000 debt to his charge card account. Do you approve or reject the mortgage application?
Group 2 saw the same paragraph with one crucial difference. Instead of learning the exact amount of the student’s debt, they were told there were conflicting reports and that the size of the debt was unclear. It was either $5,000 or $25,000. Participants could decide to approve or reject the applicant immediately, or they could delay their decision until more information was available, clarifying how much the student really owed. Not surprisingly, most Group 2 participants chose to wait until they knew the size of the debt.
Here’s where the study gets clever. The experimenters then revealed that the student’s debt was only $5,000. In other words, both groups ended up with the same exact information. Group 2 just had to go out of its way and seek it out.
The result? 71% of Group 1 participants rejected the applicant. But among Group 2 participants who asked for additional information? Only 21% rejected the applicant.
To say the findings are surprising is to state the obvious. After all, everyone had precisely the same information. So why would the rate of rejection be three times higher in Group 1?
The answer underscores a troubling blind spot in the way we make decisions. One that highlights the downside of having a sea of information available at our fingertips, and just might convince you to ditch your iPhone the next time you’re faced with an important choice.
Cliffhangers: Great for Television, Disastrous for Decisions
Remember Seinfeld and Friends? Fifteen years ago, a handful of television shows ended on cliffhangers. Daytime soaps were among the first to regularly end on a climax, and 24 made the practice a fixture of mainstream television. Today, most dramas are loathe to end an episode without one. Even comedies like The Office and Modern Family now rely on cliffhangers to draw viewers back.
There’s a psychological reason cliffhangers are so effective. The human mind hates uncertainty. Uncertainty implies volatility, randomness, and danger. When we notice information is missing, our brain raises a metaphorical red flag and says, “Pay attention. This could be important.”
Generally, that curiosity is useful. In our evolutionary past, knowing whether that rustling in the bushes belonged to a tiger or a mouse could have meant the difference between life and death. We’re wired to reduce uncertainty because our minds were adapted for another, more hazardous, time.
Seeking out information comes with a downside, however, which accounts for the intriguing difference between the two groups. When data is missing, we overestimate its value. Our mind assumes that since we are expending resource locating information, it must be useful.
Participants in Group 2 couldn’t help but ask for additional data. The mind, after all, hates information gaps. And because their attention was focused on whether the debt was $5,000 or $25,000, their thinking about the loan had shifted. They no longer saw the big picture–that the applicant had a history of defaulting. They were simply too fixated on a relatively minor detail, the size of the debt.
The Seduction of Data
The research underscores a sobering message: We’re fascinated with filling information gaps and that obsession can lead us astray. Especially today, when reducing uncertainty has become all too easy.
What’s the forecast for Friday? Pick up your iPhone. What’s Lindsey Lohan up to? Type in TMZ. Wonder what that girl from 10th grade drama now looks like? Facebook!
And it’s not just trivial information that’s easily accessible. It’s data that drives major business decisions. There’s always one more report, one more analysis, and one more perspective that’s a click or two away.
Neurologically, information is addicting. Learning is associated with the release of dopamine, the same as powerful drugs like cocaine. It’s why we are so vulnerable to an Internet rife with attention parasites that leave us worse for the wear.
In a world where every click brings the promise of a discovery, we are all at risk of becoming addicts. The challenge lies in differentiating between questions worth exploring and questions best left unasked.
Key Takeaway
Most people believe better decisions require more information. Behavioral science suggests the opposite can also be true.
Research shows that once we become aware of missing information, we instinctively assign it greater importance than it deserves. The search for certainty narrows our attention, causing us to focus on details while overlooking the larger pattern that should guide our judgment.
In the Princeton and Stanford study described in this article, participants who sought additional information ultimately made worse decisions than those who acted without it, despite both groups ending up with the same facts.
Sometimes the greatest threat to good judgment isn't ignorance. It's becoming distracted by information that feels valuable but isn't.
What This Means for Leaders
Modern organizations rarely suffer from a lack of data. They suffer from a lack of discrimination.
Leaders today have access to dashboards, analytics, market research, customer surveys, AI-generated reports, competitive intelligence, and real-time metrics. Yet many decisions don't improve as more information becomes available. They simply take longer.
The behavioral science behind this article explains why. Our brains naturally confuse uncertainty with importance. The moment we discover that something is unknown, our attention shifts toward resolving the uncertainty rather than asking whether the missing information would actually change the decision.
This helps explain a common organizational trap: analysis becomes a substitute for judgment. Teams delay action while waiting for another report, another meeting, another round of customer feedback, or another forecast. The conversation shifts from identifying the variables that truly matter to eliminating every remaining unknown. But those are not the same objective.
The best decision-makers work differently. Rather than asking, What else can we learn? they ask a more disciplined question: What information would genuinely change our decision? If the answer is "none," they move forward.
This distinction becomes even more important as artificial intelligence makes information cheaper and easier to generate. AI can summarize thousands of documents, analyze enormous datasets, and surface countless perspectives in seconds. Those capabilities are enormously valuable. But they also increase the temptation to keep searching long after the critical facts are already known.
Exceptional leaders recognize that good judgment isn't defined by how much information you collect. It's defined by knowing when you have enough. The competitive advantage increasingly belongs not to organizations with the most data, but to those that can distinguish signal from noise and act decisively when others remain trapped in analysis.
More Harvard Business Review Articles by Ron Friedman
Ron Friedman has written more than 20 articles for Harvard Business Review exploring leadership, teamwork, workplace culture, motivation, and the science of high-performing teams.
See These Ideas in Action
The research in this article is one piece of a much larger puzzle.
For more than two decades, Ron Friedman has studied the behaviors that help leaders and teams perform at their best. His research spans leadership, teamwork, collaboration, workplace culture, motivation, and the science of high-performing teams, with insights published in more than 20 Harvard Business Review articles and three bestselling books.
Today, Ron brings those discoveries to organizations around the world, translating behavioral science into practical ideas leaders can apply immediately. He has taught more than 300,000 executives and delivered keynote presentations for organizations including IBM, Amazon, Boeing, Trader Joe's, Accenture, Kaiser Permanente, Sephora, ADP, MassMutual, and Baird.